Rock Band or Guitar Hero 3? The Official Debate Thread!

Simple question really. Rock Band or Guitar Hero 3? Please give your reason why also.

Rockband=100%win

It brings so much more to the table than gh3. Rockband does have its downfalls tho, it did have better more popular song list over all but I think the guitar playing in gh3 is just as good or better than Rockband. Strictly just cause some of the songs are funner to play in GH3

ROCK BAND

not a doubt in my mind i was never very good at guitar so gh never worked for me
whereas rock band brought out the drumset as well as the mic
now teh drumset is something i can do and the songs are much more recognized
i.e. fortunate son, enter sandman

Rockband - Definitely

why you ask?
because rockband is fun and challenging, and you can get with your friends and have so much fun, whereas GH limits you go a fat guitar that sucks.

UM. ROCK BAND. IM THE NEXT FUCKING MICHAEL JORDAN OF DRUMS. ALSO, CAN HIT THOSE FUCKING HIGH NOTES ON THE GIRL SONGS.

how about, you're the next John Bonham - without dying.
not to mention, was it you who barely passed green grass and high tides on medium?

i can play just about everything but green grass and high tides on medium

actually i failed it on medium came back passed it on hard so idk what tehy were thinking when they made the notes for that song

peck, re-add me on xbox and i'll show you my drum skills.

jason wrote:

how about, you're the next John Bonham - without dying.
not to mention, was it you who barely passed green grass and high tides on medium?

on DRUMS. Beat the shit on expert guitar tho.

John Bonham was Led Zeppelins Drummer - until he died, and I 98% that on Drums on medium.

I think I five-starred every song on Medium, except Timmy & The Lords of the Underworld.

rockband because u can have a band a mic a drum set. u can make a person and customize him to your liking . u also have a better song list in my opinion. overall i would rather play rockband than gh3

rock band deff...the guitar is pretty much the same but as cuse kid said u can customize ur own guy and the drums and mic were a great add gh3 i didnt think improved that much than the one before and rock band is more fun to play with other ppl also